Discretion has never been Noah's strong point, so he's not totally shocked when his wealthy New York parents decide to send him away to Amish country for the summer. Although Noah believes his parents are punishing him for his wild indiscretions with men, they believe they're teaching Noah a lesson in life that will tame him. As a closeted gay Amish man filled with internal conflict, Filbert's entire life has revolved around keeping secrets and discretion. Although he's managed to figure out how to learn about gay culture through a part time job that gives him Internet access and a trusted best friend named Niles, he's a 24 year old gay virgin trapped in a world that will never accept him for who he is. When these two very distant cousins from completely different worlds meet for the first time, Noah makes snide jokes about Filbert's special cheese, and Filbert throws shade and sass at Noah's promiscuity. However, as the summer progresses they discover a mutual bond that's stronger than they'd expected. But is it strong enough to tame Noah's wild, reckless urges and indiscretions? And is it enough to give Filbert the courage to leave his overbearing Amish mother and the only way of life he's ever known?